Getting a new roof is no small decision—it’s like picking the outfit your house will wear for decades. Metal or shingles? Each has its personality, its costs, and its own story. When it comes to metal roof vs. shingles cost, it’s not just about today’s price tag—it’s about how you want your roof to perform, look, and last for years to come. We’ll walk you through the details so you can see which option is the perfect fit for you.
Initial Cost Considerations
The upfront expense of a metal roof can be a bit shocking. Metal roofing typically costs between $10,000 to $25,000 for an average home, depending on the type of metal you choose. Asphalt shingles seem much kinder to your budget initially, with costs ranging from $5,000 to $10,000 for a standard-sized roof.
Why is metal so pricey? You’re paying for durability, unique style, and higher-quality materials. Shingles, though cheaper at first, might require more maintenance or earlier replacement, which could cost you down the line. If you’re planning to stay in your home for decades, it’s worth calculating future expenses.
Longevity and Maintenance
When you think about the lifespan, metal roofs last significantly longer—50 years or more in many cases. Asphalt shingles typically endure around 20 to 25 years before they need replacing. If you hate the idea of climbing up a ladder every couple of years or paying someone to do it, this difference can matter.
Metal roofs are also tough. They handle hail, wind, and heavy rain like a champ. With shingles, you’ll need to prepare for more frequent fixes, especially after storms. Those smaller costs of maintaining a shingle roof can add up over time, so factor in both initial savings and future expenses when making your choice.
Energy Efficiency and Savings
Metal roofs are cool—literally. They reflect sunlight, keeping your home cooler in the summer and potentially lowering energy bills. Shingle roofs tend to absorb heat, which can make your AC work overtime. Depending on your climate and energy usage, metal roofing could help you save a bit each year on cooling costs.
But here’s the trade-off: If you live somewhere cold, that heat-absorbing quality of shingles might work to your benefit. It’s a bit like deciding if you want a metal icebox on your house or a heat-absorbing blanket.
Curb Appeal and Value
Metal roofs give homes a modern, sleek look, and they tend to stand out—sometimes quite literally, given how shiny they can be. They might boost the resale value of your home, especially if you’re marketing to buyers who appreciate longevity. Shingles, on the other hand, are the classic choice—they’re cozy, they fit in, and most folks know what to expect from them. Plus, the variety of colors and styles can suit almost any house type.
While a metal roof can elevate the style of your home, not everyone will love that futuristic vibe. Imagine your house standing there, trying to look all cutting-edge, while the neighbor’s place whispers, “Keep it classic, my friend.” Sometimes, keeping up with the Joneses means not looking like a sci-fi movie set.
Get a Durable Roof with the Best Roofing Contractor in Sioux Falls
The metal roof vs. shingles debate comes down to how long you plan to stick around and how much maintenance you’re comfortable with. Whichever option you choose, trust Harvey’s Five Star Roofing to handle every aspect of your roofing needs. We offer everything from minor repairs to full roof replacements, installations, and inspections.
Whether it’s residential or commercial roofing, our experienced team will complete the job efficiently and at a price that fits your budget. We proudly serve Sioux Falls and surrounding areas across South Dakota, Iowa, and Minnesota. With over 25 years of experience and a Five Star Warranty that guarantees quality craftsmanship, you can have complete confidence in our work.
Call us today at (712) 832-3660 for a FREE estimate, and let us make sure your roof is ready for anything.
